Fics like The best family is the one you choose

After the fiasco with Jake's father, Holt offers to be his dad. Nothing but sickly-sweet fluff (and hugs, and bonding over flip charts). Set after S2E18, Captain Peralta. No spoilers for later seasons as I haven't watched that far ahead yet.

You may also like

1. The Ladies Book Club of the Ninety-Ninth Precinct by igrockspock (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
2. Giraffes by tstate_wranglerr (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
3. on my heart like a tattoo by elsaclack (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
4. Weight by midnightdragons (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
5. our troubles will be out of sight by returnsandreturns (Daredevil (TV), Jessica Jones (TV), more)
6. 99 Bottles by mariadperiad20 (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
7. Keep Kevin Safe by mariadperiad20 (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
8. Elevator Talk by mariadperiad20 (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
9. Cold Case, Cold Night by AQuietThinker (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
10. I will look for you, I will find you and I will kill Figgis by WakeUpAndSmellTheCoffee (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
11. A False Memory (Would Be Everything) by orphan_account (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
12. Morning After by aloneintherain (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV), Marvel Cinematic Universe)
13. you, undeniable you by returnsandreturns (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
14. It's Detective Jacob Peralta, Actually by alristotle (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
15. Black Widow: From Brooklyn With Love by Wonderlander090 (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV), Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
16. No Big Deal by mariadperiad20 (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
17. Boyfriends From College by Impossibly_Izzy (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV), One Day at a Time (TV 2017))
18. When Am I? by WritingPains (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
19. Gods dammed detectives by retro_stars (Percy Jackson and the Olympians - Rick Riordan, Percy Jackson and the Olympians & Related Fandoms - All Media Types, more)
20. Faking It by PastyPirate (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))