Fics like Boyfriends From College

Jake dated two guys in college, but doesn't realise until he introduces one of them to Amy.

You may also like

1. the only proof that i need is you by elsaclack (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
2. Think Once, Think Twice by Fahye (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
3. Permanent Marker by a_s_y_n_c (Percy Jackson and the Olympians & Related Fandoms - All Media Types, Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
4. Missing, Presumed Dead by Deerlie_03 (Percy Jackson and the Olympians - Rick Riordan, Percy Jackson and the Olympians & Related Fandoms - All Media Types, more)
5. Only When Spoken To by CaptainBonnet (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
6. Run by mariadperiad20 (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
7. It Hurts (Requests Open) by orphan_account (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
8. Cars and Kidnapping by mariadperiad20 (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
9. the world's a stage by torigates (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
10. The Ebony Falcon Strikes by mariadperiad20 (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
11. everything is easier when you're home by sergeantsantiago (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
12. i could listen to you all day by startofamoment (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
13. So Soon Will Wake by RiaLuna (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
14. wham, bam, thank you ma'am by nirav (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
15. Allegations by TempestRising (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
16. five times jake drunk texts amy (and inadvertently makes her smile) and one time she does by crazykrystle (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
17. the little ones are climbing up the walls by cashewdani (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
18. Parent's Night by mariadperiad20 (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
19. Jake Peralta, Master Cunnilinguist-Slash-Genius by girlyjuice (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
20. and let your colors bleed and blend with mine by elsaclack (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))