Fics like Pretty Whites and Paperbacks (We're Not Dating, I Swear)

Will just wanted a book club. Mack just wanted to help. Now they’re fake‑dating for a couples‑only signup, sharing way too many sleepovers, and everyone else seems convinced they’re already together. A story about hockey players, bad decisions, book‑club chaos, and two idiots who are definitely not dating (or maybe they are).

You may also like

1. Everything Goes Quiet by Claydolly (Men's Hockey RPF)
2. I know how I feel about you now by itsspanner (Men's Hockey RPF)
3. Melting Ice (And The Truth Beneath The Cold) by DaisyButterfly (Men's Hockey RPF)
4. Apparently, We're Dating by Sloe_Balm (Men's Hockey RPF)
5. Salt, Coffee, and the Bathroom Floor by DaisyButterfly (Men's Hockey RPF)
6. I Keep Swimming So You Don’t See Me Drown by DaisyButterfly (Men's Hockey RPF)
7. We're Going To Be Okay by Sunshineandrainydays (Men's Hockey RPF)
8. The Breaking Point (Men's Hockey RPF)
9. best behavior by 71mack (Men's Hockey RPF)
10. I’m Gonna Miss You, Baby by jaeseul4 (Men's Hockey RPF)
11. The Kissing Disease (Or: How We Accidentally Outed Ourselves to the Entire Team) by DaisyButterfly (Men's Hockey RPF)
12. center ice by 71mack (Men's Hockey RPF)
13. The Sharks: Behind The Scenes by DaisyButterfly (Men's Hockey RPF)
14. You’ve Got My Devotion by martiuzzs (Men's Hockey RPF)
15. Forgive my insolence by dipstickinc (Men's Hockey RPF)
16. Twink Jail by JustAPersonIg (Men's Hockey RPF)
17. What We Came Back To by gothicottagecorechiv (Men's Hockey RPF)
18. Of Course There is a Free Bed? by DaisyButterfly (Men's Hockey RPF)
19. You are my trouble (Men's Hockey RPF)
20. My Captain by DaisyButterfly (Men's Hockey RPF)