Fics like May the Odds Be Ever Against Her [On Hiatus]

The Eltingville Club has a problem: endless 2-2 deadlocks on everything from whether Aliens is better than Alien to whether Return of the Jedi even counts as real Star Wars. Bill Dickey, self-appointed president and chronic arguer, decides the only solution is to recruit a fifth member, someone with knowledge, passion, and the ability to break ties (preferably in his favor). Josh Levy thinks he might know someone. An old friend from back in the day, someone he used to trade comics with and argue about X-Men until three in the morning. Someone who definitely knows their stuff and won’t back down from Bill’s gatekeeping bullshit. Someone who could actually fit right in with their dysfunctional basement club. The problem was, Josh very carefully not mentioned to Bill and the others that Y/N was, in fact, Y/N. As in, a girl.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

You may also like

  1. Is this really gonna work? by Pencilcasewriter (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  2. what're you scared of, dickey? by stickysugarkisses (The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  3. Friend's girlfriend by strawbites (The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  4. First Times by phewbs (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  5. everything you ever wanted / everything you ever thought of by greedo_318 (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  6. Eltingville Girl by Dkrose (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  7. Eltingville Club, my style by Iminsideyourbushes (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  8. ★ SWEET LIKE CANDY ! ★ | Eltingville Club x Reader by orphan_account (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  9. Good Girl by Brainr0tClown (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  10. If I Don't Get To Be Happy, Neither Do You by GutzSpillz (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  11. Are you really gonna take it like that? by phewbs (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  12. proximity (a human's touch) by Downwards_Upz_Mist (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  13. Don't Toy With Me, Mr. Dickey by Kinkikupkake (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  14. his bar maid by orphan_account (The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  15. park that car, drop that phone by julietvstheworld (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  16. Kicked to the Curb by thedudeandtheguitarist (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  17. driving in cars with boys by arachnidsForager, femininemess (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  18. Eltingville Club: No New Members (Except You) by Yui1231o (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  19. Eltingville Scenarios/Headcanons by Brainr0tClown (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  20. Appreciate the effort. by Pink_Frog (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))