Fics like Appreciate the effort.

There, bathed in the dim orange glow of a single flickering bulb, stood an altar. An altar made to be worshipped. — Pete is obsessed with Bill. Bill is not a good person to choose.

You may also like

  1. You Gave Your Love to Me Softly by orphan_account (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  2. May the Odds Be Ever Against Her [On Hiatus] by Nikushxmi (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  3. Don't Toy With Me, Mr. Dickey by Kinkikupkake (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  4. Eltingville Girl by Dkrose (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  5. Tell Me I’m Still Good by NobodyProblematic (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  6. park that car, drop that phone by julietvstheworld (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  7. Tales from the Foxhole by GarryDaOneAndOnly (Class of '09 (Visual Novel), Life is Strange (Video Game), more)
  8. Pink Kryptonite has struck The Eltingville Club. by IlliterateVincel (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  9. Incel headcanons <3 by orphan_account (The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  10. Wanna Make You Bleed by orphan_account (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  11. Eltingville Club, my style by Iminsideyourbushes (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  12. Kicked to the Curb by thedudeandtheguitarist (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  13. Friend's girlfriend by strawbites (The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  14. driving in cars with boys by arachnidsForager, femininemess (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  15. have you ever seen a star drop? by Downwards_Upz_Mist (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  16. "You and I are blood and wine" (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  17. Is this really gonna work? by Pencilcasewriter (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  18. Go On and Step On Me (The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  19. his bar maid by orphan_account (The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  20. proximity (a human's touch) by Downwards_Upz_Mist (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))