Fics like be cruel to me (cause i’m a fool for you)

your childhood family friend started ignoring you once he started hanging around with his ‘club’. On Halloween, you’re forced into proximity since neither of you got invited to anything better, and you had to attend his parents’ annual Halloween party. You didn’t get invited to a better party since your ‘friends’ think you’re not good-looking enough for them to get any kind of action. Pete thinks that any hole’s a goal. Shenanigans ensue to convince you of this fact.

You may also like

  1. Are you really gonna take it like that? by phewbs (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  2. park that car, drop that phone by julietvstheworld (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  3. Shoplifting by Ghiacciolite (The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  4. Is this really gonna work? by Pencilcasewriter (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  5. Eltingville Scenarios/Headcanons by Brainr0tClown (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  6. May the Odds Be Ever Against Her [On Hiatus] by Nikushxmi (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  7. You Can Do So Much Better by yesen1ab3lle (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  8. Eltingville club headcannons by Therealaxelchains (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), more)
  9. Friend's girlfriend by strawbites (The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  10. ★ SWEET LIKE CANDY ! ★ | Eltingville Club x Reader by orphan_account (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  11. Love You To Death by orphan_account (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  12. driving in cars with boys by arachnidsForager, femininemess (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  13. I Worship Like A Dog by mcwonn (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  14. First Times by phewbs (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  15. Girls Don’t Like Comics! by pourstiel_v (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  16. mean by orphan_account (The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  17. Sessions of a High School Freakazoid by viktorkisser (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  18. If I Don't Get To Be Happy, Neither Do You by GutzSpillz (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  19. Spring Break Sleepover by thedudeandtheguitarist (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  20. wanna see you bleed by orphan_account (The Eltingville Club (Comics))