Fics like Starfall in Eltingville

When a mysterious alien girl crash-lands in the backyard of horror nerd Pete DiNunzio, the lives of the Eltingville Club are turned upside down. She’s taken in and hidden by the boys, who quickly become obsessed with her otherworldly nature. As they try to keep her secret from the rest of the world (Idk if you could tell im Pete bias) (Not gonna like its sorta like eleven and how they were with her in stranger things)

You may also like

  1. Eltingville Club: No New Members (Except You) by Yui1231o (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  2. Kicked to the Curb by thedudeandtheguitarist (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  3. park that car, drop that phone by julietvstheworld (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  4. Welcome 2 Eltingville by Real_Squiddo (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  5. "You and I are blood and wine" (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  6. Tell Me I’m Still Good by NobodyProblematic (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  7. Move for Me by orphan_account (The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  8. Don't Toy With Me, Mr. Dickey by Kinkikupkake (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  9. May the Odds Be Ever Against Her [On Hiatus] by Nikushxmi (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  10. Virgin with Rage by phewbs (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  11. Eltingville Club drabbles by vaniilakiss (The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  12. driving in cars with boys by arachnidsForager, femininemess (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  13. You Gave Your Love to Me Softly by orphan_account (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  14. NSFW ALPHABET : The Eltingville Club (NCC Bonus) (The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  15. curious nerd by thatonestrangedude (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  16. Eltingville Girl by Dkrose (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  17. The regulars by R4spbearry (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  18. The Boyfriend Experience by phewbs (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))
  19. Girls Don’t Like Comics! by pourstiel_v (Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002), The Eltingville Club (Comics))
  20. I'm a Lot Like You, So Please, Hello by jamessunderlandlover1983 (The Eltingville Club (Comics), Welcome to Eltingville (Cartoon 2002))