Fics like The Lost Heart's Dilemma

Tensions rise among the Lost Boys when all four of them develop feelings for Michael. As their desires clash, David intervenes before things escalate into violence. He suggests a unique solution: each of them will have the opportunity to take Michael out on a date, allowing him to choose who he wants to be with. The one Michael chooses will become his vampire mate. This proposal sets the stage for a series of romantic dates as each vampire competes for Michael's affection, leading to unexpected revelations and a final decision that will reshape their relationships forever. I'm keeping this rated Teen for now but it may change.

You may also like

  1. A-Z The Lost Boys Alphabet...Part 2! by darjeelingdreams (The Lost Boys - Fandom, The Lost Boys (Movies))
  2. To Live(Again!) Would Be An Awfully Big Adventure by PrincessMeggala0913 (The Lost Boys (Movies))
  3. Peer Pressure is a Killer by milfwillgraham (The Lost Boys (Movies))
  4. The Purest Expression Of Grief. by Them_bo (The Lost Boys (Movies), The Lost Boys - Hoch/Hornsby/The Rescues)
  5. you can watch me corrode like a beast in repose by partiallyobscure (The Lost Boys (Movies))
  6. A Day Without Night by madrabbitwrites (The Lost Boys (Movies), The Lost Boys - Hoch/Hornsby/The Rescues)
  7. Runaway Boy by FranticallyChaotic (The Lost Boys (Movies), The Lost Boys - Hoch/Hornsby/The Rescues)
  8. Essential As Sunlight by EowynOakheart (The Lost Boys - Hoch/Hornsby/The Rescues, The Lost Boys (Movies))
  9. Blink by Adryyr (The Lost Boys (Movies))
  10. Melody Unchained by Nikki666 (The Lost Boys (Movies))
  11. Lost In The Shadows by januaryjo16 (The Lost Boys (Movies))
  12. Give Up Forever by madrabbitwrites (The Lost Boys (Movies), The Lost Boys - Hoch/Hornsby/The Rescues)
  13. The Grave Keeper by ItStaredBack (The Lost Boys (Movies))
  14. Oh, Loverboy by Theyreonlynoodles (The Lost Boys (Movies))
  15. Never Neverland by magicalnarwhaldust (The Lost Boys (Movies))
  16. Assisted Dying by MaraMcGregor (The Lost Boys (Movies))
  17. Boardwalks and Sunken Hotels by dream3create (The Lost Boys (Movies))
  18. Even the Stars Fall by Portraitofafool (The Lost Boys (Movies))
  19. A Stake Through the Heart Would Have Been Kinder, But You Missed My Heart and Broke Yours Instead by Astral_Weaver (The Lost Boys (Movies), The Lost Boys - Hoch/Hornsby/The Rescues, more)
  20. You're a Mirror I Cannot Avoid by ohaubergine (The Lost Boys (Movies), The Lost Boys - Hoch/Hornsby/The Rescues)