Fics like The Second Time

Paxton heard through the grapevine about Ben and Devi messing around. "It was supposed to be me, Devi."

You may also like

1. always should've been you by KatiePaterow (Never Have I Ever (TV))
2. hey baby, waste your time with me in california by thekittenthatreads (Never Have I Ever (TV))
3. So Jealous by crystalkei (Never Have I Ever (TV))
4. you and me, Oui by thekittenthatreads (Never Have I Ever (TV))
5. The Distance Between Us by to_be_real_now (Never Have I Ever (TV))
6. whenever you're ready by shapesintheclouds26 (Never Have I Ever (TV))
7. My Home is Your Body by crystalkei (Never Have I Ever (TV))
8. but now you're dizzy again by orphan_account (Never Have I Ever (TV))
9. all over again by orphan_account (Never Have I Ever (TV))
10. eager, young (and abandoning) by cori_the_bloody (Never Have I Ever (TV))
11. Never Have I Ever...Loved Someone Like You by Brown_eyed_paradox (Never Have I Ever (TV))
12. 85 percent by thekittenthatreads (Never Have I Ever (TV))
13. knights by orphan_account (Never Have I Ever (TV))
14. i've had no love like your love by rosegoldenglows (Never Have I Ever (TV))
15. Five to Seven Years Early or Two Weeks Late by crystalkei (Never Have I Ever (TV))
16. 3 Nights in Arizona by chb4art (Never Have I Ever (TV))
17. no amount of freedom gets you clean (i still got you all over me) by peterpan_in_neverland (Never Have I Ever (TV))
18. Blurred Lines by to_be_real_now (Never Have I Ever (TV))
19. so what about these feelings i've got by magnetichearts (Never Have I Ever (TV))
20. i'm forever chasing after time by flashlightinacave (Never Have I Ever (TV))