Fics like always should've been you

In which Devi attends what she thinks is another boring party until Ben drunkenly asks her if he's unlovable.

You may also like

1. so what about these feelings i've got by magnetichearts (Never Have I Ever (TV))
2. 85 percent by thekittenthatreads (Never Have I Ever (TV))
3. So Jealous by crystalkei (Never Have I Ever (TV))
4. i'm forever chasing after time by flashlightinacave (Never Have I Ever (TV))
5. belvedere by shiliszt (Never Have I Ever (TV))
6. Never Have I Ever... Helped Someone Grieve by RSmoak (Never Have I Ever (TV))
7. whenever you're ready by shapesintheclouds26 (Never Have I Ever (TV))
8. Loathing you, Always and Forever by BetterNameToCome (Never Have I Ever (TV))
9. lost in your current like a priceless wine by fantasize (Never Have I Ever (TV))
10. Just Waiting for a Girl Like You by cleverly (Never Have I Ever (TV))
11. i'm just fine, 'cause i know that you are mine by magnetichearts (Never Have I Ever (TV))
12. eager, young (and abandoning) by cori_the_bloody (Never Have I Ever (TV))
13. share your address by tworoads (Never Have I Ever (TV))
14. call me crazy, call you baby by thekittenthatreads (Never Have I Ever (TV))
15. i hate accidents except when we went from friends to this by flashlightinacave, magnetichearts (Never Have I Ever (TV))
16. you're lost and you're alone and you can't get back again by magnetichearts (Never Have I Ever (TV))
17. a lie away from getting you into the mood by cori_the_bloody (Never Have I Ever (TV))
18. knights by orphan_account (Never Have I Ever (TV))
19. look at this godforsaken mess that you made me by my_middle_name_is_awkward (Never Have I Ever (TV))
20. but now you're dizzy again by orphan_account (Never Have I Ever (TV))