Fics like Captain of the Swim Team

Melissa offers to go with you to your 10 year reunion but you don’t expect her to go so far when your ex shows up

You may also like

1. Little Pitchers by dionaeamuscipula (Abbott Elementary (TV))
2. Bigfoot Doesn’t Exist by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
3. Homegrown Tomatoes by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
4. Sweet Cheeks - Melissa Schemmenti x OC (wlw) by gay4women00 (Abbott Elementary (TV), Melissa Schemmenti - Fandom, more)
5. Perish the Thought, Jacob Hill by telm_393 (Abbott Elementary (TV))
6. Fritole by thesexfiles (Abbott Elementary (TV))
7. Slow Dancing in the Dark by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
8. New by pripripro (Abbott Elementary (TV))
9. The Wooing of Melissa Schemmenti by frizz22 (Abbott Elementary (TV))
10. i'm glad it left a mark by overtureenvelops (Abbott Elementary (TV))
11. stop the world i wanna get off with you by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
12. I Choose You by earpivore (Abbott Elementary (TV))
13. A Love Rewritten by Abbottfan7 (Abbott Elementary (TV))
14. Pancakes for Dinner by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
15. Fictional Milf Oneshots by lyssiesroses (Multi-Fandom, Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
16. i will count myself new by beanierose (Abbott Elementary (TV))
17. collude by beanierose (Abbott Elementary (TV))
18. The Anniversary of Taking Back My Life by Noelism (Abbott Elementary (TV))
19. The Assigned Seat by gaynahmontana (Abbott Elementary (TV))
20. how to want what you can't have by thesexfiles (Abbott Elementary (TV))