Fics like A Love Rewritten

Returning to Abbott Elementary was never part of your plan. But when you're hired as the new vice principal, you’re forced to face the one person you never truly got over—Melissa Schemmenti. Years ago, you were just a student teacher with a reckless heart, falling for someone you had no business loving. Now, standing in front of her again, it’s clear that time hasn’t erased what was left unresolved. And from the way Melissa refuses to meet your eyes, you can tell—she still feels it too.

You may also like

  1. A Favour from 2016 by Aeve_fagan (The Pitt (TV), 9-1-1 (TV), more)
  2. To Get Her Back, I Had To Sweater by scullysaveme (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  3. stop the world i wanna get off with you by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  4. all of it (all of you) by hausofval (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  5. For Keeps by earpivore (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  6. what’s heaven to a woman’s love anyway? by beanierose (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  7. Sweet Cheeks - Melissa Schemmenti x OC (wlw) by gay4women00 (Abbott Elementary (TV), Melissa Schemmenti - Fandom, more)
  8. what's a loss of blood when you win a bit of dirt? by the_frankenman_writes (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  9. Homegrown Tomatoes by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  10. I Can't Behave Around You by bonesofsapphire (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  11. Slow Dancing in the Dark by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  12. Downhill, Uphill by callmeyours (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  13. Warning Label by strawberryfieldsss (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  14. The Other Woman by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  15. Little Pitchers by dionaeamuscipula (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  16. Dark Horse by aspirationalpeony (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  17. You're the only Redhead I want by BadBatch (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  18. gladly break my heart for you by charlottepriestly (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  19. Pavor Diurnus by callmeyours (Abbott Elementary (TV))
  20. Friends by pripripro (Abbott Elementary (TV))