Fics like I Choose You

You’re the new third grade teacher at Abbott Elementary and from the moment you saw Melissa Schemmenti walk across the parking lot on your very first day, you knew she was something special. You never could have imagined all that would happen between you or how knowing her would change your life in the most incredible ways.

You may also like

1. Slow Dancing in the Dark by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
2. Perish the Thought, Jacob Hill by telm_393 (Abbott Elementary (TV))
3. if this is an emergency by telm_393 (Abbott Elementary (TV))
4. all of it (all of you) by hausofval (Abbott Elementary (TV))
5. Forever Is The Sweetest Con by callmeyours (Abbott Elementary (TV))
6. Fritole by thesexfiles (Abbott Elementary (TV))
7. Fictional Milf Oneshots by lyssiesroses (Multi-Fandom, Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
8. Sweet Cheeks - Melissa Schemmenti x OC (wlw) by gay4women00 (Abbott Elementary (TV), Melissa Schemmenti - Fandom, more)
9. Sorry, Hon. by earpivore (Abbott Elementary (TV))
10. tell her you love her by literary_lesbian (Abbott Elementary (TV))
11. Pancakes for Dinner by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
12. Pretty Young Thing by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
13. trooping with crows by theartistformerlyknownas (Abbott Elementary (TV))
14. Wow! The Temperature In Hell Is Actually So Pleasant by telm_393 (Abbott Elementary (TV))
15. For Keeps by earpivore (Abbott Elementary (TV))
16. Trust Me by Monochromely (Abbott Elementary (TV))
17. I Can't Behave Around You by bonesofsapphire (Abbott Elementary (TV))
18. Huh, Who the Hell Knew? by earpivore (Abbott Elementary (TV))
19. say anything but don’t say goodbye by kitnkabootle (Abbott Elementary (TV))
20. stop the world i wanna get off with you by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))