Fics like Lilith in the Wood

When Father Paul laid eyes on you, soaked to the bone and shifting anxiously from side to side on his porch, he stepped out of the doorway to make room for you. “Come in,” he intoned softly. When Erin made you go to church with her that Sunday, you never imagined it would lead you here. Shameless reader-insert, smut starting in the 4th chapter.

You may also like

1. Romans 12:1 (Midnight Mass (TV))
2. Absit by ToeBeansMcGee (Midnight Mass (TV))
3. the hush of the very good by chronicghost (Midnight Mass (TV))
4. heart-shaped box by cakecakecake (Midnight Mass (TV))
5. sacramentum by pondslime (Midnight Mass (TV))
6. Seven Seals (Midnight Mass (TV))
7. Knell - Multi Fandom Reverse Isekai by taylorbean (The Lord of the Rings - All Media Types, Sinners (2025), more)
8. You Know Better by hflowers (Midnight Mass (TV))
9. one day when i was lost he died upon that cross by elithewho (Midnight Mass (TV))
10. Striking the Match by paperhoneycombs (Midnight Mass (TV))
11. let no one separate by femalecynic (Midnight Mass (TV))
12. Midnight Delight (Midnight Mass (TV))
13. BOOK I: Be Not Afraid by qesii (Midnight Mass (TV))
14. Carnal Desires by localmothman (Midnight Mass (TV))
15. Communion Rite by raphae11e (Midnight Mass (TV))
16. Hawkshaw by localmothman (Midnight Mass (TV))
17. Praying for salvation by Tears_and_smiles (Midnight Mass (TV))
18. Abaddon Sheol by DoctorWanderer (Doctor Who, The Hour (TV), more)
19. Hidden Cove by TheMultitudesOfMe (The Midnight Club (TV), Midnight Mass (TV))
20. Cherry Picking by NoseBridgePinch (Stranger Things (TV 2016), Midnight Mass (TV))