Fics like You Know Better

"Under normal circumstances, you would’ve been right. But here’s the small jewel of truth that even Paul himself hated looking at: he did not want to save you." Or, In which Y/N is sent to Crockett Island for their self-destructive behaviors, and though Father Paul knows better, he can't resist.

You may also like

  1. Lilith in the Wood by MissScaryKitty (Midnight Mass (TV))
  2. the hush of the very good by chronicghost (Midnight Mass (TV))
  3. heart-shaped box by cakecakecake (Midnight Mass (TV))
  4. thy kingdom come by nighimpossible (Midnight Mass (TV))
  5. Heat (Midnight Mass (TV))
  6. sacramentum by pondslime (Midnight Mass (TV))
  7. Comet Lovers by TheMultitudesOfMe (The Midnight Club (TV), Midnight Mass (TV), more)
  8. Parent/Teacher Night by formerly_drabbletastic (Midnight Mass (TV))
  9. Everything's Edenic by paperhoneycombs (Midnight Mass (TV))
  10. the only way to live forever by bluesyturtle (Midnight Mass (TV))
  11. Midnight Delight (Midnight Mass (TV))
  12. one day when i was lost he died upon that cross by elithewho (Midnight Mass (TV))
  13. Shared Blessings by Mishka10 (Midnight Mass (TV))
  14. Triple Stack Of Cuteness by TheMultitudesOfMe (The Fall of the House of Usher (TV 2023), Midnight Mass (TV), more)
  15. let no one separate by femalecynic (Midnight Mass (TV))
  16. show me how to save my soul by whiteshipnightjar (Midnight Mass (TV))
  17. Every Breaking Waves by MidnightEvaB (Midnight Mass (TV))
  18. A Collection of Father Paul x Reader Drabbles by CopiArion (Midnight Mass (TV))
  19. confessions and benders by seemeinacrown (Midnight Mass (TV))
  20. Cherry Picking by NoseBridgePinch (Stranger Things (TV 2016), Midnight Mass (TV))