Fics like Catch of the collar (The Night Father Paul Removed His Collar)

“You certainly made sure I noticed you tonight, didn’t you y/n?” His soft voice sounds uncharacteristically hoarse. You hold his gaze. “Yes… Father”. He looks like he’s making an effort to stay composed, but his breathing is too fast (...)

You may also like

  1. sacramentum by pondslime (Midnight Mass (TV))
  2. Romans 12:1 (Midnight Mass (TV))
  3. Knell - Multi Fandom Reverse Isekai by taylorbean (The Lord of the Rings - All Media Types, Sinners (2025), more)
  4. heart-shaped box by cakecakecake (Midnight Mass (TV))
  5. Every Breaking Waves by MidnightEvaB (Midnight Mass (TV))
  6. I Forgive it All as it Comes Back to Me by eviegreyog4 (Twin Peaks (TV 1990), Buffy the Vampire Slayer (TV), more)
  7. The Shepherd and the Lamb by Loopy_duck (Midnight Mass (TV))
  8. Lead Us Not Into Temptation by orphan_account (Midnight Mass (TV))
  9. Seven by formerly_drabbletastic (Midnight Mass (TV))
  10. ships passing in the night by spellboundspectre (Midnight Mass (TV))
  11. Seven Seals (Midnight Mass (TV))
  12. Search narrowly the lines! - they hold a treasure//Divine- a talisman- an amulet//That must be worn at heart. by TheMultitudesOfMe (The Fall of the House of Usher (TV 2023), Midnight Mass (TV), more)
  13. I Feel Evil Creeping In by Kasiarzyna (Midnight Mass (TV))
  14. Through the Darkness by mareyshelley (Midnight Mass (TV))
  15. Parent/Teacher Night by formerly_drabbletastic (Midnight Mass (TV))
  16. Complete Honesty by orphan_account (Midnight Mass (TV))
  17. Saints Swimming In Our Sins Again by vampire_dove (Midnight Mass (TV))
  18. Midnight Delight (Midnight Mass (TV))
  19. show me how to save my soul by whiteshipnightjar (Midnight Mass (TV))
  20. Cherry Picking by NoseBridgePinch (Stranger Things (TV 2016), Midnight Mass (TV))