Fics like Lead Us Not Into Temptation

You volunteer to help out at St. Patrick's one night, and you end up getting a lot closer to Father Paul than you expected.

You may also like

  1. The Night Father Paul Let You Sit on His Lap by PlainLo_inthemorning (Midnight Mass (TV))
  2. Triple Stack Of Cuteness by TheMultitudesOfMe (The Fall of the House of Usher (TV 2023), Midnight Mass (TV), more)
  3. Midnight Delight (Midnight Mass (TV))
  4. Romans 12:1 (Midnight Mass (TV))
  5. The Shepherd and the Lamb by Loopy_duck (Midnight Mass (TV))
  6. sacramentum by pondslime (Midnight Mass (TV))
  7. heart-shaped box by cakecakecake (Midnight Mass (TV))
  8. Seven by formerly_drabbletastic (Midnight Mass (TV))
  9. thy kingdom come by nighimpossible (Midnight Mass (TV))
  10. confessions and benders by seemeinacrown (Midnight Mass (TV))
  11. Through the Darkness by mareyshelley (Midnight Mass (TV))
  12. Together, In Solitude by angeIic666 (Midnight Mass (TV))
  13. Baptismal Font by raphae11e (Midnight Mass (TV))
  14. The Belly of the Wicked Shall Want by daughter0fcain (Midnight Mass (TV))
  15. one day when i was lost he died upon that cross by elithewho (Midnight Mass (TV))
  16. Lilith in the Wood by MissScaryKitty (Midnight Mass (TV))
  17. Way Down We Go by fretnotdearheart (Midnight Mass (TV))
  18. ships passing in the night by spellboundspectre (Midnight Mass (TV))
  19. Heat (Midnight Mass (TV))
  20. guilty pleasure by MiniskirtAlert (The Hobbit (Jackson Movies), The Lord of the Rings (Movies), more)