Fics like The Shepherd and the Lamb

When Riley is attacked by the Angel on his way home after a meeting, John rushes to his rescue. The Angel refuses to give Riley his blood, despite John's pleas. Knowing it will forever bind them together in irreversible ways, John changes him himself and brings him back to the rectory. Riley decides to give his new life a chance - but only because John promises to help him and to keep him and his loved ones safe. The two have plenty to talk about and a connection neither of them can ignore. And who knows - maybe Riley can help John see the error of his ways...

You may also like

1. Midnight Delight (Midnight Mass (TV))
2. Striking the Match by paperhoneycombs (Midnight Mass (TV))
3. thy kingdom come by nighimpossible (Midnight Mass (TV))
4. show me how to save my soul by whiteshipnightjar (Midnight Mass (TV))
5. heart-shaped box by cakecakecake (Midnight Mass (TV))
6. Hidden Cove by TheMultitudesOfMe (The Midnight Club (TV), Midnight Mass (TV))
7. Knell - Multi Fandom Reverse Isekai by taylorbean (The Lord of the Rings - All Media Types, Sinners (2025), more)
8. sacramentum by pondslime (Midnight Mass (TV))
9. confessions and benders by seemeinacrown (Midnight Mass (TV))
10. The Book of Ecclesiastes by nicen (Midnight Mass (TV))
11. ships passing in the night by spellboundspectre (Midnight Mass (TV))
12. Romans 12:1 (Midnight Mass (TV))
13. baby, you need to leave (cause I'm getting drunk on your noble deeds) by scorpiod (Midnight Mass (TV))
14. guilty pleasure by MiniskirtAlert (The Hobbit (Jackson Movies), The Lord of the Rings (Movies), more)
15. the hush of the very good by chronicghost (Midnight Mass (TV))
16. Seven by formerly_drabbletastic (Midnight Mass (TV))
17. the only way to live forever by bluesyturtle (Midnight Mass (TV))
18. Carnal Desires by localmothman (Midnight Mass (TV))
19. Saints Swimming In Our Sins Again by vampire_dove (Midnight Mass (TV))
20. Have Mercy by gormlaith420 (Midnight Mass (TV))