Fics like Where Angels Fear to Tread

An AU where the reader, in the time of John Michael Pruitt’s youth, is set up to be married to him. Hesitant at first of this arrangement with someone she barely knows, John decides to become a man of the cloth to prevent the marriage from happening. But, by that point, he’s already fallen and so have you. //requested by noctvrnalmoth Can the choices we make ever be undone? // “Romance is a game for fools" I said and grinned Then you passed by And here am I Throwing caution to the wind // (Completed)

You may also like

1. heart-shaped box by cakecakecake (Midnight Mass (TV))
2. sacramentum by pondslime (Midnight Mass (TV))
3. Catch of the collar (The Night Father Paul Removed His Collar) by PlainLo_inthemorning (Midnight Mass (TV))
4. show me how to save my soul by whiteshipnightjar (Midnight Mass (TV))
5. Communion Rite by raphae11e (Midnight Mass (TV))
6. Striking the Match by paperhoneycombs (Midnight Mass (TV))
7. You Know Better by hflowers (Midnight Mass (TV))
8. I Feel Evil Creeping In by Kasiarzyna (Midnight Mass (TV))
9. the hush of the very good by chronicghost (Midnight Mass (TV))
10. Romans 12:1 (Midnight Mass (TV))
11. Baptismal Font by raphae11e (Midnight Mass (TV))
12. Hawkshaw by localmothman (Midnight Mass (TV))
13. Saints Swimming In Our Sins Again by vampire_dove (Midnight Mass (TV))
14. Heat (Midnight Mass (TV))
15. confessions and benders by seemeinacrown (Midnight Mass (TV))
16. Song of Solomon by catsfromspace (Midnight Mass (TV))
17. Midnight Delight (Midnight Mass (TV))
18. Cherry Picking by NoseBridgePinch (Stranger Things (TV 2016), Midnight Mass (TV))
19. Knell - Multi Fandom Reverse Isekai by taylorbean (The Lord of the Rings - All Media Types, Sinners (2025), more)
20. Hidden Cove by TheMultitudesOfMe (The Midnight Club (TV), Midnight Mass (TV))