Fics like keeping our eyes open (for something great)

"I kissed Stephanie."

You may also like

1. Things you said... by The_Breaths_of_Chloe (Good Witch (TV))
2. Serendipity by xfphile (Good Witch (TV))
3. writings on the inside of your wrist by dearingsattler (Good Witch (TV))
4. capsized staring on the edge of safe by dearingsattler (Good Witch (TV))
5. It's Magic... by CottonPerriwood (Good Witch (TV))
6. Middleton Vacation by Literally_No_One_Cares (My Babysitter's A Vampire, Good Witch (TV))
7. haven't you people ever heard of knocking? by dearingsattler (Good Witch (TV))
8. I'm a Good Witch by The_Grey_Lady (Good Witch (TV))
9. Joy in a Box by idk_books (Good Witch (TV), Wynonna Earp (TV))
10. Pumpkin Spice Kisses by serenity_sky (Good Witch (TV))
11. Feel by BiJane (Good Witch (TV))
12. diving in by cinematicnightmare (Good Witch (TV))
13. Beautiful Ghosts by ddamaged (Wynonna Earp (TV), Good Witch (TV))
14. oh sweet summer child let me bestow this knowledge upon thee by dearingsattler (Good Witch (TV))
15. call me now, baby (and i'd come a-runnin') by lawand_disorder (Good Witch (TV))
16. Confession by writerchic16 (Good Witch (TV))
17. Secrets Revealed by The_Grey_Lady (Good Witch (TV))
18. Water Under the Bridge by Emowolf10 (Good Witch (TV), Twisted-Wonderland (Video Game))
19. Wanderlust: Tuscany by lawand_disorder (Good Witch (TV))
20. The Witch and the Boy Prince by QueenoftheWallflowers (Good Witch (TV))