Fics like I'm a Good Witch

When did Sam finally find out the truth about Cassie being a witch? We'll never know for sure, but my guess is that it was somewhere around the end of season 4. This story takes place the day after the ending of episode 4.09, "How to Make a Middleton Quilt."

You may also like

1. Serendipity by xfphile (Good Witch (TV))
2. Day Trip by The_Grey_Lady (Good Witch (TV))
3. Rumors by writerchic16 (Good Witch (TV))
4. Secrets Revealed by The_Grey_Lady (Good Witch (TV))
5. Connections by writerchic16 (Good Witch (TV))
6. It's Magic... by CottonPerriwood (Good Witch (TV))
7. I Just Wanted To Say by xXxAngelStormxXx (The good witch - Fandom, Good Witch (TV))
8. Moments Unseen by The_Grey_Lady (Good Witch (TV))
9. Resisting Temptations by The_Grey_Lady (Good Witch (TV))
10. Confession by writerchic16 (Good Witch (TV))
11. Friends First by witch0000 (Good Witch (TV))
12. strong as an oak but soft like leather by gaypurgatory, wynhaaught (Wynonna Earp (TV), Good Witch (TV))
13. Things you said... by The_Breaths_of_Chloe (Good Witch (TV))
14. You over mine by 6coolaish6 (Good Witch (TV))
15. Middleton Vacation by Literally_No_One_Cares (My Babysitter's A Vampire, Good Witch (TV))
16. Without Interruptions by The_Grey_Lady (Good Witch (TV))
17. A Prelude to...Something by lawand_disorder (Good Witch (TV))
18. Unwanted Baggage (Please Return to Sender) by xfphile (Good Witch (TV))
19. The Couch by The_Grey_Lady (Good Witch (TV))
20. My Bandmates A Vampire by TransSeinfeld (My Babysitter's A Vampire, Radio Rebel (2012), more)