Fics like Joy in a Box

Wynonna Earp somehow ends up in Middleton but the real mystery is how is Joy Harper meant to convince her that she is not called Nicole Haught?

You may also like

1. The Grind by odaatlover (Wynonna Earp (TV))
2. My Queen by JumpyNinja (Wynonna Earp (TV))
3. No Expectations by reusabletears (Wynonna Earp (TV))
4. Open Range Hearts by thewaywedo33 (Wynonna Earp (TV))
5. for the price of seven good cows by coldmackerel (Wynonna Earp (TV))
6. Looking For You by dance_tilyouredead (Wynonna Earp (TV))
7. Couldn't Help Falling For You by JNS (Wynonna Earp (TV))
8. find a home, lonely heart by tigerlo (Wynonna Earp (TV))
9. countless stars we're sleeping under by biblionerd07 (Wynonna Earp (TV))
10. Whenever I'm alone with you (you make me feel like I am young again) by darcy81 (Wynonna Earp (TV))
11. it's like i wrote every note with my own fingers by gilligankane (Wynonna Earp (TV))
12. For The Kingdom, But Mostly For Her by S_Bender780 (Wynonna Earp (TV))
13. Our Place by orphan_account (Wynonna Earp (TV))
14. One-Eighty by sensitive_pigeon (Wynonna Earp (TV))
15. The Bodyguard (but make it Wayhaught) by ashbash13 (Wynonna Earp (TV))
16. Double Cross by gooseclaws (Wynonna Earp (TV))
17. Painted Walls and Hardwood Floors by New54321 (Wynonna Earp (TV))
18. Catch Me When You Can by wrackwonder (Wynonna Earp (TV))
19. Not a Cheap Date by ChompJames (Wynonna Earp (TV))
20. There are things I wish I never knew, but none of them are you by JNS (Wynonna Earp (TV))