Fics like take me to sturch (stage church)

Jake Peralta and Amy Santiago are a Classic™ example of a theater rivalry– competing for roles as long as they can remember, striving to be Holt's favorite student actor (his favorite is Gina, but no one needs to know that). The dynamics of Jake and Amy's rivalry start to twist when they enter high school, getting cast as romantic leads year after year. They begrudgingly put up with this— until senior year rolls around and they find out that they have to kiss on stage.

You may also like

Think Once, Think Twice by Fahye (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
five times jake drunk texts amy (and inadvertently makes her smile) and one time she does by crazykrystle (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
if you’re lost out where the lights are blinding by arachnistar (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
the only proof that i need is you by elsaclack (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
you can hear it in the silence by elsaclack (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
on my heart like a tattoo by elsaclack (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
The Ebony Falcon Strikes by mariadperiad20 (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
keep your head up (i'll lay my heart down) by sassywriterchick (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
i could listen to you all day by startofamoment (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
Six Little Rules by RubyCaspar (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
everything is easier when you're home by sergeantsantiago (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
So Soon Will Wake by RiaLuna (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
Not Your Son by mariadperiad20 (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
Static by beetmu (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
Margin of Error by idiopathicsmile (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
and i know, i'm not alone, you'll be watching over us (until you're gone) by EffieTrinket1619 (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
for you are my fate by lymans (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
so close to reaching that famous happy end by startofamoment (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
the world's a stage by torigates (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV))
Boyfriends From College by Impossibly_Izzy (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV), One Day at a Time (TV 2017))