Fics like Five Times Ichabod Kissed Abbie (and one time he didn't)

Ichabod's not taking advantage; he's just improvising. Right? (post John Doe)

You may also like

1. a more perfect Union by scifisis (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
2. Something Mundane, Okay? by dumbender (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
3. All Dolled Up by scifisis (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
4. One Fine Day by nestorius (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
5. Darcy Lewis vs. the Multi-Verse by aForgottenWeasley (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), Thor (Movies), more)
6. The Extraordinary Presidents by RandolphChurchill (The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Hamilton - Miranda, more)
7. In Plain Sight (So Open Your Eyes) by scifisis (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
8. Sugar by aurorstorm (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
9. An Unknown Known by awriterthatwrites (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
10. In the Still of the Night by CallMeElle (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
11. Barriers by CreepingMuse (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
12. Future’s So Bright, I Gotta Wear Shades by wanttobeatree (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
13. Stay by sneetchstar (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
14. Five Times Abbie Explained That Ichabod Is Married (and one time she reminded herself) by audreyii_fic (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
15. Five Women Ryan Stone Met On the Road (And One Man She Technically Never Did) by xenakis (Gravity (2013), Sleepy Hollow (TV), more)
16. A Gentleman's Dare by MissMaudlin (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
17. On the Clear Understanding by samyazaz (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
18. Entwining Threads by FateChica (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
19. Pollen by TheSmutFaries (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
20. In Dreams by sneetchstar (Sleepy Hollow (TV))