Fics like A Gentleman's Dare

“I bet you can’t do it.” Crane licked her collarbone. “And what is that?” “Have sex with me—seduce me—in a public place. You’re too chicken to do it.” Crane stilled. Then he looked up at her with those eyes—ugh, she loved his eyes like she loved his eyebrows—and replied, “Are you daring me, Miss Mills?”

You may also like

1. a more perfect Union by scifisis (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
2. Five Times Abbie Explained That Ichabod Is Married (and one time she reminded herself) by audreyii_fic (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
3. The 12 Days of Smutmas by MissMaudlin (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
4. Archived by awriterthatwrites (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
5. You Always Want What You're Running From by fairytalesandfolklore (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
6. Within by CreepingMuse (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
7. Can't Pin You Down by iamtheenemy (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
8. Syzygy by recrudescence (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
9. Devil Put Aside For Me by follow_the_sun (Captain America (Movies), Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
10. Darcy Lewis vs. the Multi-Verse by aForgottenWeasley (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), Thor (Movies), more)
11. Pollen by TheSmutFaries (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
12. Five Times Abbie Tries to Teach Ichabod to Drive, and the One Time Nothing Explodes by wolflings (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
13. In Plain Sight (So Open Your Eyes) by scifisis (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
14. Trust and Love by CastleriggCircle (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
15. Yours, Ichabod: Letters of Love and Lust between the Captain and the Lieutenant by CreepingMuse, JWAB (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
16. Five Times Abbie Introduced Ichabod To Fast Food (and one time he didn't complain) by audreyii_fic (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
17. An Unknown Known by awriterthatwrites (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
18. Ichabod and Abbie's Continuing Adventures in: Having a Baby by Cumberbatch%20Critter (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
19. Five Times Ichabod Was Appalled By Netflix (and one time Abbie got sick) by audreyii_fic (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
20. All Dolled Up by scifisis (Sleepy Hollow (TV))