Fics like Sugar

Ichabod makes a choked noise of disapproval as he watches Abbie pop an Oreo straight into her mouth. She raises an eyebrow. “You didn’t follow the instructions,” he protests, holding up the package he had been studying so intently. Abbie is confused for a moment until she remembers: twist, lick, dunk. [Ichabod, Abbie and sugar.]

You may also like

1. The Hellhound of the Rockefellers by Flourish (Elementary (TV), Sleepy Hollow (TV))
2. Welcome To Cascade - Broken Snow by Paula%20Cas (NCIS, The Sentinel (TV), more)
3. a more perfect Union by scifisis (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
4. Everything Old Is New Again by samyazaz (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
5. Brighter Than the Sun by killabeez (Lost Girl, Merlin (TV), more)
6. Five Times Ichabod Kissed Abbie (and one time he didn't) by orphan_account (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
7. One Fine Day by nestorius (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
8. Such a Thing of Wonder in the Crowd by The_Unnatural_Disaster (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
9. You Always Want What You're Running From by fairytalesandfolklore (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
10. Is There a Law? (The Demon Machine remix) by blathering_kat, fiarra (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
11. Five Times Abbie Introduced Ichabod To Fast Food (and one time he didn't complain) by audreyii_fic (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
12. Five Times Ichabod Doesn't Give Up His Coat (and one time he does) by audreyii_fic (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
13. By Word, By Deed by mautadite (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
14. Darcy Lewis vs. the Multi-Verse by aForgottenWeasley (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), Thor (Movies), more)
15. Seventeen times Bad Wolf Interfered by Eshnoazot (Doctor Who, Doctor Who (2005), more)
16. Can't Pin You Down by iamtheenemy (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
17. Entwining Threads by FateChica (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
18. Must be that Magic Touch by Lady_Talla_Doe (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
19. On the Clear Understanding by samyazaz (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
20. In Dreams by sneetchstar (Sleepy Hollow (TV))