Fics like Take Me to Church

5 times Eddie feels something but Catholic guilt silences him, and 1 time he decides to give everything for the person he loves.

You may also like

1. Can I Have This Dance? by Jonasdirection101 (9-1-1 (TV))
2. Forever Winter by Jonasdirection101 (9-1-1 (TV))
3. you're as sweet as strawberry wine by izzyonionberry (9-1-1 (TV))
4. panic, promises & pancakes by adoringbuck (9-1-1 (TV))
5. Floating Now by jimhoppersfloralshirt (9-1-1 (TV))
6. Why? by buckmeetsboy (9-1-1 (TV))
7. I Hold On To Anything That Sets Me Free... by orphan_account (9-1-1 (TV))
8. Drowning On Dry Land by jack_a_rose (9-1-1 (TV))
9. Whispers, Words, and Wounds by FandomLife54 (9-1-1 (TV))
10. I Do (I Really, Really Do) by eightpackdiaz (9-1-1 (TV))
11. Mind Over Matter by Jonasdirection101 (9-1-1 (TV))
12. Lost & Found by Jonasdirection101 (9-1-1 (TV))
13. bites and bikes by OnlyForBuddie (9-1-1 (TV))
14. Calling All Witches by inkinmyheartandonthepage (9-1-1 (TV))
15. a true love’s kiss by snowyroads (9-1-1 (TV))
16. Window Seat at Sunrise by Idachen (9-1-1 (TV))
17. Baby just say yes by scarmaddiewrites (9-1-1 (TV))
18. Interrupting Kisses by Plz_send_help27 (9-1-1 (TV))
19. Loving you is the easiest thing I’ve ever done by delusional_fangirl118 (9-1-1 (TV))
20. If You Said I Do I Would Too by giselleslash (9-1-1 (TV))