Fics like Matchmaking

“Have you guys kissed?” Coy asks abruptly. That works too, Anthony guesses. Anthony really doesn’t know how Coy gets away with it—if he asked, Coy would just say something about his positive energy—but he does, because Paul Baker nods, and Anthony has to clamp his teeth together to prevent his jaw from dropping. “Well, yeah,” Paul Baker says. “The night of our wedding.” Can we make a stranger fall in love? Bunch of Friends is out on the streets of NYC, competing to see who can create a couple the fastest. Paul Baker is the easiest target they've ever had.

You may also like

1. old and new friends by showmeIove (Heated Rivalry (TV), Adults (TV 2025), more)
2. Paul Baker Has Gay Dads?! (9-1-1 (TV), Adults (TV 2025))
3. brick by brick by wafflesofdoom (Adults (TV 2025))
4. Never Too Much by DragonBinx (Adults (TV 2025))
5. abstinence is just a state of mind by rinpanna (Adults (TV 2025))
6. the cure by wafflesofdoom (Adults (TV 2025))
7. Hungry Eyes by seaofswirls (Adults (TV 2025))
8. and i got a feeling wounds are healing by professional_girlkisser (Adults (TV 2025))
9. are you ever dreaming of me? by patrickbrewer (Adults (TV 2025))
10. She Was Adopted By Bunch of Friends?! by Scritchy_Scratchy_Scrutchy, cjFruitya, ineedsomebedresr, kittercritter (Bunch of Friends | BunchofFriendsYT (Video Blogging RPF))
11. (look into my eyes and baby whisper) fool by tvlandia (Adults (TV 2025))
12. Bad Advice by ignoresagain (Adults (TV 2025))
13. fall into me and then... by blipbloop (Adults (TV 2025))
14. dog days are over by colonoscopys (Adults (TV 2025))
15. i feel right, i feel wrong, i feel totally insane by rinpanna (Adults (TV 2025))
16. You Ought to Give Me Wedding Rings by DragonBinx (Adults (TV 2025))
17. thank them for an empty house. by kmsquill (Adults (TV 2025))
18. The Paul Baker Look by DragonBinx (Adults (TV 2025))
19. Sex Pests by ignoresagain (Adults (TV 2025))
20. he brought a fucking glowstick by bratbuckley (Adults (TV 2025))