Fics like Hey, good-looking, what's cooking?

Anton Evans matches with Paul Baker on Grindr, expecting nothing more than a little late-night flirting. Then, by complete accident, they run into each other at a packed club in New York, and the chemistry is somehow even more intense in person.

You may also like

1. you feel brand new for the millionth time by loopforever (Adults (TV 2025))
2. other boys may need a map by Japery (Adults (TV 2025))
3. abstinence is just a state of mind by rinpanna (Adults (TV 2025))
4. Sex Pests by ignoresagain (Adults (TV 2025))
5. thank them for an empty house. by kmsquill (Adults (TV 2025))
6. brick by brick by wafflesofdoom (Adults (TV 2025))
7. faggots for brains by rinpanna (Adults (TV 2025))
8. fall into me and then... by blipbloop (Adults (TV 2025))
9. what can i do, but think of you? by rinpanna (Adults (TV 2025))
10. you're scared of love (well aren't we all?) by wafflesofdoom (Adults (TV 2025))
11. annulments by dejame (Adults (TV 2025))
12. Birthday Boy by Raveniant (Adults (TV 2025))
13. Three Days later by Knmsjn06 (Adults (TV 2025))
14. you can't run from the urge by rinpanna (Adults (TV 2025))
15. Paul Baker Has Gay Dads?! (9-1-1 (TV), Adults (TV 2025))
16. You're All That I Have, But Can't Get by infinitysynth (Adults (TV 2025))
17. yeah (oh no, wait a minute) x10 by loopforever (Adults (TV 2025))
18. The Paul Baker Look by DragonBinx (Adults (TV 2025))
19. Marathon Day by moonlightpresence (Adults (TV 2025))
20. Paul Baker Thinks Shane Hollander is ‘Nasty’ at Hockey by isto4u (Heated Rivalry (TV), Adults (TV 2025))