Fics like The Second First Time

First Chapter: The party in Red Hook (Philip's POV) Second Chapter: The afterparty alone in Philip's bedroom (Lukas's POV)

You may also like

1. At Night, Alone by that_1_incident (Eyewitness (US TV))
2. small town american light by yourcrookedheart (Eyewitness (US TV))
3. You saved me by Achillesishere (Eyewitness (US TV))
4. Counting to Fifteen by secondstar (Eyewitness (US TV))
5. A Golden Pocket Watch by SaintVier (Eyewitness (US TV))
6. Aftershocks by trulymadlylarry (Eyewitness (US TV))
7. Sweet Like Sugar by kooky500 (Eyewitness (US TV))
8. Big Green Monster by justbekind (Eyewitness (US TV))
9. Control by FiftyShadesOfStyles (Eyewitness (US TV), SKAM (TV))
10. stomach aches by brookewormed (Eyewitness (US TV))
11. made for each other by andromedagalaxy (Eyewitness (US TV))
12. It Would Be Lukas by JuxtaposeFantasy (Eyewitness (US TV))
13. Dirty Windows by semi_problematic (Eyewitness (US TV))
14. Resentment by StonedWitch (Eyewitness (US TV))
15. Oh the die is cast inside my mind by kooky500 (Hannibal (TV), Eyewitness (US TV))
16. Between Our Heavenly Bodies by Waste_the_night (Eyewitness (US TV))
17. I'll give you the moon by andromedagalaxy (Eyewitness (US TV))
18. Endorphins by justbekind (Eyewitness (US TV))
19. Words on My Skin by Crescence (Eyewitness (US TV))
20. Sorry I'm Late by andromedagalaxy (Eyewitness (US TV))