Fics like P.S. It's Me

Penny Argent wants nothing to do with Phebe Ward. She's spending her energy where it counts, obviously- on the mysterious persona she has been emailing for the past two years, who she has fallen hopelessly in love with. But when one of her best friends falls head over heels for Phebe's best friend, suddenly she might find herself spending a lot of time with a someone she thought she would never have anything in common with. But how is Penny supposed to choose between her heart and what's right in front of her?

You may also like

  1. Moving Day by Jessika_Thorne (Mutants & Masterminds (Roleplaying Game), Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game), more)
  2. Calling Home by Jessika_Thorne (Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game), Silver Age Sentinels (Roleplaying Game), more)
  3. Tinkering in the Garage by Jessika_Thorne (City of Heroes (Video Game), Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game), more)
  4. Too Far Gone by SharkNaando (The Extracurriculars (Masks: A New Generation), Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game))
  5. punching (but charged) (and maybe with assault) (oops) (DCU (Comics), Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game), more)
  6. Silence and Darkness by Cherry_Slushiez, unremarkable_half_elf (Original Work, Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game))
  7. Masks: Play Time by Taysha_lee_44 (Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game))
  8. Sparks in the Darkness by Jessika_Thorne (City of Heroes (Video Game), Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game), more)
  9. too much heaven on their minds by Indigo_404 (Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game), Halcyon City: Earth-22)
  10. Meet Your Heroes by dragonLeighs (Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game))
  11. Proud by SharkNaando (Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game), The Extracurriculars (Masks: A New Generation))
  12. The Plot of the Pedagogue by Lady_of_the_Seraphim (Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game), Nemesis - April Daniels, more)
  13. The Unstoppable Empress! Issue #1 by CrepuscularReverie (Original Work, Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game))
  14. It Will Come Back by queendirtface (Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game), The Extracurriculars (Masks: A New Generation))
  15. Mutated Story (WIP) by The_writer_of_lies (X-Men - All Media Types, Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game), more)
  16. Odyssey of Choice by Masquerade_Wraith (EPIC - Jorge Rivera-Herrans (Albums), Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game))
  17. Toxic by KaosComics (Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game), The Extracurriculars (Masks: A New Generation))
  18. Another Night Spent Relaxing by Jessika_Thorne (Mutants & Masterminds (Roleplaying Game), Silver Age Sentinels (Roleplaying Game), more)
  19. Bible Camp by dragonLeighs (Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game))
  20. Intermission I by Jessika_Thorne (City of Heroes (Video Game), Masks: A New Generation (Roleplaying Game), more)