Fics like I Know You'll Be A Star In Someone Else's Sky (But Why Can't It Be Mine)

"Tears pool, again. I jam the letter back in its hiding spot and lock the drawer. I repeat the mantra I internalised years ago; Hannah Wells is my best friend and I will not be the guy who spoils that by wanting more. I’ll hurt her. She deserves better." John Logan, Garrett Graham's best friend, asked him if it was okay to ask Hannah Wells, Garrett's other best friend, out on a date. Garrett had said yes. He wouldn't be weird about this. He was fine. Garrett isn't fine with this. Because Garrett has been in love with Hannah, his best friend since they were both five years old, for as long as he can remember. He never found the courage to confess, too afraid he'd hurt her, and now Garrett can feel the future he once envisioned with Hannah slipping away from him. But even if he isn't fine, Garrett will pretend he is. Because what matters is that the two people he cares about more than anyone else are happy.

You may also like

  1. light on by DarkOrchiid (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  2. Off the Record by shippingsailor (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  3. Garrett's Girls by PetalsAndPlotTwists (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  4. Falling Just As Hard by CiaraSky (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  5. A Different Kind of Deal by LoverLullaby (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  6. I’ll build my world around you, I need you so by flissfloo (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, more)
  7. A Love Story: Garrett and Hannah, Part 1 by deloise_1 (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  8. Call It Fate, Call It Karma by Savasta_101 (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  9. The Bitch Is Back by somewhereintheafterglow (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  10. Did You Ever Think of Me? by misssophiachase (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, more)
  11. is it casual now? by serendipitysirius (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  12. I Like You-Deal With It by UnWellsyGrahamsy44 (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  13. Living in Sin by bottomlessnonsense (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  14. Mr. Perfect by GeorgiaGlass (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  15. longer than we planned, better than we thought by piglemousse (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  16. In between the lines by clairesmh (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Off Campus (TV 2026))
  17. Benched by Heartbreak by JustBWilde (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  18. Where the Cracks Let Light In by WriteMyAnchor (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Off Campus (TV 2026))
  19. with my heart in my chest (and the clouds of my breath) by sometimesiship (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  20. The Summer of Seventeen by somewhereintheafterglow (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)