Fics like Benched by Heartbreak

Allie was always the relationship type. Dean was more into hookups and flirting. It was supposed to be just a casual distraction after her breakup. Somehow, Dean ended up the one with a broken heart. Continuation of the story after the first season.

You may also like

  1. it's hard to love in the cold (but, boy, it's time i tried) by PrincessOfNothingCharming (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  2. The Blood Drive by Poppy_Hennings (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Off Campus (TV 2026))
  3. A Love Story: Garrett and Hannah, Part 1 by deloise_1 (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  4. Garrett's Girls by PetalsAndPlotTwists (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  5. Where the Cracks Let Light In by WriteMyAnchor (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Off Campus (TV 2026))
  6. The only test I wanna ace is you by AmandaLovegood (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  7. My Broken Bones are Mending by misssophiachase (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, more)
  8. Not Like Last Time by Imagine_Epic (Off Campus (TV 2026), Criminal Minds (US TV))
  9. Melody Wells by Imagine_Epic (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  10. 2 bad bitches at the same damn time by hakuna_matata (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  11. A Different Kind of Deal by LoverLullaby (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  12. The Bitch Is Back by somewhereintheafterglow (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  13. Curl Theory by somewhereintheafterglow (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Off Campus (TV 2026))
  14. Off the Record by shippingsailor (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  15. Splitsville by HoneyHolliday (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  16. with my heart in my chest (and the clouds of my breath) by sometimesiship (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  17. Wanna Meet Up & Give Me a Goodnight Kiss? by JustBWilde (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  18. I Like You-Deal With It by UnWellsyGrahamsy44 (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  19. I’ll build my world around you, I need you so by flissfloo (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, more)
  20. Falling Just As Hard by CiaraSky (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)