Fics like I Believe In This Thing Called Magic

A reworking of the canon material but blending some book stuff and adding some Naley parallels to the story. May diverge from canon at times. Mentions of Hannah's past SA amd Garrett's abuse so be aware of that. Smutty as hell. Garrett's a horn dog for Hannah but he's a respectful one. "I try to shake away all those thoughts and try ignore him and his stupid sexy body. I've sworn off jocks forever. No more. One traumatizing jock enough for a lifetime. Just because Garrett Graham has an awesome dick doesn't mean anything besides I'm horny and need to have sex with someone."

You may also like

  1. Did You Ever Think of Me? by misssophiachase (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, more)
  2. Within These Walls by JessJ7890 (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  3. I’ll build my world around you, I need you so by flissfloo (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, more)
  4. The Point I'm Trying to Make by dragonxxdancer (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Off Campus (TV 2026))
  5. Off the Record by shippingsailor (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  6. The Golden Ratio by gigawattbeaming (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  7. Call It Fate, Call It Karma by Savasta_101 (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  8. Benched by Heartbreak by JustBWilde (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  9. Garrett's Girls by PetalsAndPlotTwists (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  10. Melody Wells by Imagine_Epic (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  11. all the pieces fall right into place by iguessthisismenow (Off Campus (TV 2026), Elle Kennedy's Off Campus - All Media Types, more)
  12. devestatingly sinful. by Miss%20Singer (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  13. Where the Cracks Let Light In by WriteMyAnchor (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Off Campus (TV 2026))
  14. The Bitch Is Back by somewhereintheafterglow (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  15. Last call by Oka113 (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  16. Off Limits by FrostedAurora (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  17. Falling Just As Hard by CiaraSky (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  18. Unsportsmanlike Conduct by PrimaveraSarah (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  19. The Other, Other Idea by BleedingMascara (Off Campus (TV 2026))
  20. A Different Kind of Deal by LoverLullaby (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)