Fics like But I'm a Creep, I'm a Weirdo.
You accept a craigslist ad that definitely didn't have enough information, but you'd do anything for a quick buck...right?
You may also like
- Senseless by PastelCaterpillar (Creep (Movies 2014 2017), The Creep Tapes (TV))
- Komaeda Is A Creep by borbles (Dangan Ronpa Series, Super Dangan Ronpa 2, more)
- i may look like i'll eat you up by sandpapersnowman (Creep (Movies 2014 2017))
- Purgatory of the Heart by Elder (Creep (Movies 2014 2017), The Creep Tapes (TV))
- Subject Of Interest by methappropriate (Creep (Movies 2014 2017), The Creep Tapes (TV))
- How would you kill me? by R0b0Bits (Creep (Movies 2014 2017), The Creep Tapes (TV))
- Horror Movies Headcanons II by macabrebatz (IT (Movies - Muschietti), Terrifier (Movies - Leone), more)
- do i creep you out? by sabrewulf (Creep (Movies 2014 2017), The Creep Tapes (TV))
- Ms. Noir's Kinktober Fest 2026 by angeliccorpse (Peacemaker (TV 2022), Scream (Movies), more)
- I contradict myself (no, I don't) by sandpapersnowman (Creep (Movies 2014 2017))
- Slasher Preferences & Headcanons by multifandomwritings (The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Movies), The Boy (2016 Bell), more)
- Hungry Like the Wolf (Creep (Movies 2014 2017))
- The Animal Inside of You by Katydid2022 (Creep (Movies 2014 2017), The Creep Tapes (TV))
- 31 Days of Falloween 2025 by akimikono (Hannibal Lecter Tetralogy - Thomas Harris, 30 Days of Night (2007), more)
- No matter what I did to you, you believed I was good and would do you no harm. by DropDeadDandy (Interview with the Vampire (TV 2022), Creep (Movies 2014 2017))
- It's my birthday, I'll kill if I want to by new-pseudo-cause-im-selfish (Creep (Movies 2014 2017), The Creep Tapes (TV))
- a little bit dangerous by sandpapersnowman (Creep (Movies 2014 2017))
- Wolf Inside You by damien (Creep (Movies 2014 2017))
- you’re so very special by m0urningstars (Creep (Movies 2014 2017))
- Sleep with me by Ihaspancake (Creep (Movies 2014 2017))