Fics like Brother's Keeper

When supernatural forces result in the disappearance of her brother, Carmen is introduced to the world of things that go bump in the night–and the men who hunt them, Sam and Dean Winchester. Being instructed to call upon the eldest of the monster-hunter duo should trouble come knocking, Carmen makes the call, and her world is turned upside down.

You may also like

Not Your Typical Case by blueniverse (Supernatural (TV 2005), Criminal Minds (US TV))
Wrong Hell, Same Brothers by Peanutbuttercat124 (Supernatural (TV 2005), Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
Fly By Night by Omera (Supernatural (TV 2005))
Do you mean to stay?// If you need to leave by Khylan_Robinson (Supernatural (TV 2005))
Hunter and The Witch by Nutellanda (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Supernatural (TV 2005))
Tuesday's Child by Ravens_Game (Supernatural (TV 2005))
This Curse On Our House by Imaginationfever (Supernatural (TV 2005))
Unlikely Connections by copperboom82 (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Supernatural (TV 2005))
Ahead of Schedule by Zeke21 (Supernatural (TV 2005))
Babylon The Great by godmadeaterribleerror (Supernatural (TV 2005))
A Dumb Blonde And An Evil Lawyer Walk Into A Bar by MaryPSue (Supernatural (TV 2005), Legally Blonde (Movies))
Carry On, My Wayward Son by JessalynMichele (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Twilight Series - Stephenie Meyer, more)
The House Finch by Black_Birb (Supernatural (TV 2005))
A Snowball's Chance by kiaraz (Supernatural (TV 2005), Buffy the Vampire Slayer (TV))
Echoes of a Cursed Kinship by Padfootette (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Supernatural (TV 2005))
Act of God by juliiawrites (Supernatural (TV 2005))
Hail Mary, Mother of Grace by EchoOfWrens (Project Hail Mary (2026), Project Hail Mary - Andy Weir, more)
he's so good to me and to nobody else (so you should watch yourself) by nettlesfordean (Supernatural (TV 2005))
So It Goes In The Impala by MelodyMannix (Supernatural (TV 2005))
Purple rings by Spiriko (Criminal Minds (US TV), Supernatural (TV 2005))