Fics like Would You Like Some Pie with That?

Finally able to retire from hunting, Sam and Dean exchange swords and chain mail for pies and aprons, opening a coffee shop for everyone in need of a little mood boost. The civilian life goes swell until Sam finds a strange man slumped by their front door. A man who, as it turns out, is not exactly a man.

You may also like

  1. No Man's Land by Alaisabel (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  2. The Fourth Horseman by NinjaPandaScholar (Supernatural (TV 2005), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
  3. blasphemy & sacrilege by soldejunio (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  4. more than just an instrument of pain by ad_castra (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  5. The Unquiet Soul by I_Am_A_Silver_Lining (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  6. Armageddon (revisited) by Not_default (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  7. both sides now by killedbythecatacombs (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  8. Even Light Casts Shadows by DarkSun, jessies_girl (Supernatural, Supernatural (TV 2005))
  9. this is the map of my heart by need_more_meta (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  10. every man you've ever been by according2thelore (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  11. house song by according2thelore (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  12. You're Speaking My Language (It's You) by pawmunkey (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  13. Paws Pressed Into Stardust by aghostofaghost (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  14. You, My Curse (You, My Cure) by need_more_meta (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  15. Walk A Broken Line by cheesecakekiss (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  16. Starve it out of Me by cobrodependent (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  17. Ahead of Schedule by Zeke21 (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  18. See Something Say Something by ShanaStoryteller (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  19. it's only death that's all (what is that to love) by need_more_meta (Supernatural (TV 2005))
  20. When You Wish Upon A Star by Merenwen76 (Supernatural (TV 2005))