Fics like Should We?

They swore they'd get it over with.

You may also like

1. Although We Never Will by perfectlystill (iCarly)
2. iForgot by axrnlly (iCarly)
3. Your Body Broke Your Fall by perfectlystill (iCarly)
4. you’re the barrel, i’m the bullet by orphan_account (iCarly)
5. it's my right to be hellish by sonseulsoleil (iCarly)
6. Say Yes by randomsass (iCarly, Sam & Cat (TV))
7. iEnyoyed the kiss by Jesusprincess16 (iCarly)
8. Possessive Pronouns by axrnlly (iCarly)
9. iRevel by axrnlly (iCarly)
10. Six Times and Counting by certainti (iCarly)
11. living under a paper moon (cause real life just isn't right) by sonseulsoleil (iCarly)
12. Shut Up and Dance With Me by axrnlly (iCarly)
13. (we weren't meant for each other and it's fine) but if the world was ending, you'd come over, right? by aletterinthenameofsanity (iCarly)
14. Way Back Into Love by axrnlly (iCarly)
15. iHave the Last Brownie by KamiNytha (iCarly)
16. Some of the Firsts by axrnlly (iCarly)
17. Don't Forget to Press the Button by sam_flowers (iCarly)
18. iCan't See the Signs by NeoNails (iCarly)
19. Change in Plans by TheWrtrInMe (iCarly)
20. Right as Rain by TheWrtrInMe (iCarly)