Fics like save the horse *checks notes* fingerfuck a cowboy?

Martyn squirms as he stares into the man's dark eyes, both from the eye contact and the heavy pressure in his gut. “You're a real pretty sight like this, you know that?” Sausage says, and there's something so genuine in it Martyn wants to flinch away. It's frightening. Martyn doesn't like getting attached to people, and he's caught himself feeling something far too fond for this man many times already. i wrote most of this immediately after martyn's first stream ended but i got too tired to finish it so i present it to you now . Yeah

You may also like

1. Oakhurst Notes by ToTheGhast (Vampires SMP, Life Series | 3rd Life SMP Series, more)
2. i don't want to say goodbye 'cause this one means forever by Nine_Red_Tails (Cowboy SMP)
3. life isn't that simple by 0RIrelish (Rats SMP, Cowboy SMP, more)
4. The world froze around us, you kissed me goodnight. by M3m0rizingM1m1 (Cowboy SMP)
5. Same Old Country Love Song (But It's GAY) by M_Lavendr5 (Cowboy SMP)
6. nobody's soldier by froggyjumps (Cowboy SMP)
7. A deck of shuffled cards by AlexTheNerd (Pantheon SMP, Vampires SMP, more)
8. The Great (Accidental) Scott Swap by R1nEatsWalls (Origins SMP, Vampires SMP, more)
9. Fortune in Pity by smol_ARTIC_FOX (Cowboy SMP)
10. teaching the preacher to lay by fagmeister (Cowboy SMP)
11. Charades by Mx_Dandy_the_frog (Cowboy SMP)
12. To Dwelleth in Love by anylifeonmars (Life Series | 3rd Life SMP Series, Cowboy SMP)
13. Behind the Saloon by A_Random_Entity (Cowboy SMP)
14. The Apo Of My Eye by Autumnintheinbetween (Cowboy SMP)
15. an injury reveals our true colors, i suppose by orphan_account (Cowboy SMP)
16. You Are Someone I Have Loved (but never known) by puppethatexists (Cowboy SMP)
17. if you give a man a gnarpy, they might just want three by thoughtsofamoth (Cowboy SMP)
18. Barstools by TheHydra9802 (Cowboy SMP, Hermitcraft SMP, more)
19. Flashbacks by A_Random_Entity (Cowboy SMP)
20. the big one by namesarehard27 (New Life SMP, impossible smp, more)