Fics like Gary’s Nice Guy Card

Gary fills a “Nice Guy Card” with five dubious “good deeds,” claiming it earns him Pete’s virginity. His relentless teasing leaves Pete mortified, fueling Gary’s smug, flirtatious antics.

You may also like

1. interest and equivocality by t4blecloth (Bully (Video Games))
2. Chamber of Reflection by farded (Bully (Video Games))
3. Gaming All Stars: Beyond by Great1 (Super Mario & Related Fandoms, Sonic the Hedgehog - All Media Types, more)
4. Can't sleep. by Worms110 (Bully (Video Games))
5. no seriously what’s wrong with this guy? by orphan_account (Bully (Video Games))
6. Bullworth Love Connection by Mini0n (Bully (Video Games))
7. Be Careful What You Ship For by solace_saphylos (Bully (Video Games))
8. Friends and Brothers by BetweenTownleys, squidnapped (Bully (Video Games))
9. We All Fall Down by INMH (Bully (Video Games))
10. Jimmy Hopkins' Prom Date Rejections by FizzleFudge (Bully (Video Games))
11. What's Left and What to Do About It by SpaceKase (Bully (Video Games))
12. I'm not Sick but I'm not Well by skull_girrl (Bully (Video Games))
13. Skip Day by csi_sanders1129 (Bully (Video Games))
14. Go away from my window by OkSalem (Bully (Video Games))
15. Shiny Happy Psychos by ochideluna (Bully (Video Games))
16. Summer by SniperRequiem (Bully (Video Games))
17. Greasers Vandalized by lone_fish (Bully (Video Games))
18. Who would have thought Earnest Jones would have an admirer? by NerdzSin (Bully (Video Games))
19. Obsession. by smopkinspilled (Bully (Video Games))
20. A Fighting Chance by csi_sanders1129 (Bully (Video Games))