Fics like The Familiar's Return

After a quiet night takes an unexpected turn, you find yourself drawn back into the orbit of two witches who once owned your soul. Your bond as their Familiar begins to pull tighter, reigniting flames you’d long buried. In the shadows of magic and desire, you must navigate old connections, simmering tension, and a power that refuses to let you go. - OR - You flirt with Alice to make Agatha and Rio jealous so they fuck you to put you back in your place

You may also like

  1. Save a horse (ride a cowboy) by OmegathaHarklez (Agatha All Along (TV))
  2. creator, you destroy me by velvetprayer (Agatha All Along (TV), Marvel Cinematic Universe)
  3. Lights, Camera, Magic by lunargrrrl (Agatha All Along (TV), WandaVision (TV), more)
  4. Death's Echo by EchoesInTheMargins (Agatha All Along (TV))
  5. find yourself in someone (you were there all along) by empathyhoodie, evgar, mondaychild (Agatha All Along (TV))
  6. someday we will all be lying on our backs (free at last from income tax) by paddingtonfan69 (Agatha All Along (TV))
  7. As seen on TV! by Echolux (Agatha All Along (TV))
  8. witchcraft filling your void by wariangle (Agatha All Along (TV))
  9. A Night to Remember by midwestprincess_01 (Agatha All Along (TV))
  10. my safeword is safeword by AnonFandomBandit, orphan_account (Agatha All Along (TV))
  11. the lordosis reflex by AnonFandomBandit, orphan_account (Agatha All Along (TV))
  12. Well I Wonder by midwestprincess_01 (Agatha All Along (TV))
  13. what if it's not meant for me? by seasalttears (Agatha All Along (TV))
  14. i looked to the children (i drank from the fountains) by seabiscuit (Agatha All Along (TV))
  15. Sugar and Honey by visadero (Agatha All Along (TV))
  16. the way i feel about you baby can’t explain it by seabiscuit (Agatha All Along (TV))
  17. A Lesson in Witchcraft by blob_ross (Agatha All Along (TV))
  18. let me desecrate you by AnonFandomBandit (Agatha All Along (TV))
  19. For Your Consideration by Salong3 (Agatha All Along (TV))
  20. tip of my tongue (sweet and sour) by agatharioluvr (Agatha All Along (TV))