Fics like Truth is Not Always Appearance

In 2024, medium Kate Linton is led to Sleepy Hollow by her spirit guide, Aliena, who promises to tell her the truth of the legend of the Headless Horseman. In 1777, young Aliena Hawke is shipped off to Europe to marry a stranger, only to discover an unexpected connection with her taciturn husband. When he’s killed in battle, she flees to the place of his death: a small farming town in the Hudson Highlands called Sleepy Hollow. In 1799, Sleepy Hollow is tormented by a murdering ghost, drawing an eccentric police constable from New York to investigate: Aliena’s estranged cousin, Ichabod Crane. Eager to see him succeed, Aliena offers her assistance, knowing that he’s her best chance to discover the truth that she knows deep down. A truth that seems impossible. The Headless Horseman is her husband.

You may also like

  1. I Won't Smile (but I'll show you my teeth) by LadySlytherin (Teen Wolf (TV), Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  2. The Ancient Ones Endure by MarianneGreenleaf (Sleepy Hollow (1999), The Legend of Sleepy Hollow - All Media Types)
  3. Abkehr by zzoaozz (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  4. Safer Grounds by juucbox (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  5. A Year to the Day by Cameo (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  6. TV/Film One-Shots by VioletAdler0224 (Unforgettable (TV), Sleepy Hollow (1999), more)
  7. Am I In Love With a Murderer? by Ivy_angel06 (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  8. Late Night Visitor by lilac_lungs (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  9. Hymeneal Dreame by MarianneGreenleaf (Sleepy Hollow (1999), The Legend of Sleepy Hollow - All Media Types)
  10. Mercy (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  11. Falsetto by Ketakoshka (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  12. Villainy Wears Many Masks by Kadorienne, irisbleufic (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  13. Into the Woods by orphan_account (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  14. A New Start by DJFireHawk (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  15. Four Little Words Challenge by RussianWitch (Phantom of the Opera (2004), Van Helsing (2004), more)
  16. I Don't Want To Miss A Thing by IchabodCranesLeftFoot (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  17. The Legend of Sleepy Hollow by Dkarpenter (Hannibal (TV), The Legend of Sleepy Hollow - Washington Irving, more)
  18. Confessions by orphan_account (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  19. The Case of Ichabod Crane and Dr. Frankenstein by Kadorienne (Sleepy Hollow (1999), Frankenstein - Shelley)
  20. Our Melody - Johnny Depp by MiniskirtAlert (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies), Sweeney Todd (2007), more)