Fics like A New Start

Ichabod Crane is fascinated by the Horseman and his Darkness, but still terrified that the dark figure will try to kill him. The horseman is curious about the man that faints at the sight of him, yet has the courage to fight the witch. When Ichabod returns his head to him the Horseman realizes that he has no desire to let the man leave.

You may also like

  1. Winter's Kiss by zzoaozz (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  2. Mercy (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  3. Villainy Wears Many Masks by Kadorienne, irisbleufic (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  4. Falsetto by Ketakoshka (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  5. In Awe by MarianneGreenleaf (Sleepy Hollow (1999), The Legend of Sleepy Hollow - All Media Types)
  6. Safer Grounds by juucbox (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  7. Our Melody - Johnny Depp by MiniskirtAlert (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies), Sweeney Todd (2007), more)
  8. Abkehr by zzoaozz (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  9. Far From New York by DreamlightRose (Sleepy Hollow (1999), The Legend of Sleepy Hollow - All Media Types)
  10. Am I In Love With a Murderer? by Ivy_angel06 (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  11. The Case of Ichabod Crane and Dr. Frankenstein by Kadorienne (Sleepy Hollow (1999), Frankenstein - Shelley)
  12. Four Little Words Challenge by RussianWitch (Phantom of the Opera (2004), Van Helsing (2004), more)
  13. A Year to End All Years by CameoSF (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  14. That Has Such People In It by Heathersparrows (Eroica Yori Ai o Komete | From Eroica with Love, Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  15. Truth Or Dare(Devil) by YunaYamiMouto (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  16. Hazbin Hollow by orphan_account (Hazbin Hotel (Web Series), Helluva Boss (Web Series), more)
  17. At peace at last by RussianWitch (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  18. so no head? by fairyysoup (The Legend of Sleepy Hollow - All Media Types, Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  19. Into the Woods by orphan_account (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
  20. Drawn To You by CecilWolford (Sleepy Hollow (1999))