Fics like If At First You Don't Succeed
"Natsu!" Lucy cheered from behind him. She stumbled clumsily from the crowd as he whirled around to face her. Natsu chewed the fire in his mouth, glaring suspiciously at her. He carefully pulled his flaming chicken leg away from her as she came to a stuttering stop in front of him, tugging at his sleeve excitedly. Her breath smelled like alcohol. He should have known he couldn't trust his partner with Cana. Lucy held up a cheap plastic ring, a flirty smile painted on her face. "Marry me." Natsu couldn't help but roll his eyes. Swallowing roughly, he said, "Lucy, you never remember." -OR- Five times Lucy proposed to Natsu and forgot, and one time she remembered (plus one more time she forgot).
You may also like
- Nalu - A twist in time by Amara22 (Fairy Tail)
- Assembly Required by indraaas (Fairy Tail)
- Astral by Deadgirluniverse (Fairy Tail, Naruto)
- it's a timeless verity. by %E3%83%AA%E3%83%AA%E3%82%B9%20-%20riris (Fairy Tail)
- Summoner's Path To Protect by orphan_account (Fairy Tail)
- The Key(s) to Victory by riddlethis (Fairy Tail)
- Frost Burned by orphan_account (Fairy Tail)
- Poison Fairy by GemNika (Fairy Tail)
- Unlocking a Closed Heart by Sairey13 (Fairy Tail)
- From Sub Goal to Soulmate, Oops by rachey (Fairy Tail)
- Devour the Light Of Heaven by Bekbek (Fairy Tail)
- the (-3) year quest by orphan_account (Fairy Tail)
- Natsu Dragneel the Dual Dragon Slayer by JTZ29 (Fairy Tail)
- The Last Cake by Smoochynose (Fairy Tail)
- every scrap of you would be taken from me by nnoragamis (Fairy Tail)
- Ad Meliora by oOAshookaOo (Fairy Tail)
- louder than words by aitnes (Fairy Tail)
- Fairy Tail's little Light by FoofyFang (Fairy Tail)
- wishing upon a star by metanoia_girl (Fairy Tail)
- your heart, my heart by aitnes (Fairy Tail)