Fics like Moonlit Sins

Upon death the Smiling critters are sent to an afterlife, for most of them it's paradise, a second life away from the pain and suffering they endured at Playtime Co, but for Catnap, it's an even worse hell than Playtime ever was as he's forced to suffer and pay for all his sins. Will he ever get a chance to truly repent? And will the others ever forgive him, or will his eternity in the afterlife be nothing but pain and suffering at the hands of those he wronged in the past, especially Dogday?

You may also like

  1. What’s the Time? (Playtime) by SissiReads_Unicorn26 (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  2. The Cat's Out Of The Bag by MidnightMare247 (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  3. Twisted Secrets by Tuliptheanimatronicskunk (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  4. Home is where the heart is (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  5. Fracture by SharVerose (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  6. Vicious by sydoctsarg (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  7. A guide on how to get rid of a pesky dog. (Spoiler, you can't.) by Imnotevenheresobye (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  8. Poppy Worldwide: TRUE SALVATION ROUTE by Mizpa (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  9. Potential (Harley Sawyer x Reader/ Player) by CreativeBlossom96 (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  10. Prototype x Fem!Toy!Reader Headcanons by StrangeAnon (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  11. I am Sorry, Children by crumblingcogs (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  12. A Poppy Flower In Your Hands, A Bloom of Emotion In My Heart by NarativeCurations (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  13. The Supervisor by SamaryCalderon (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  14. Poppy Worldwide: SALVATION ROUTE by Mizpa (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  15. Cat Got Your Tongue? by MidnightMare247 (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  16. Full House by DucksAreLife (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  17. Guardian Angel by Bunvunny (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  18. Innovation Is Key (May We Forget Death) by calypso_willow (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  19. Guardian Angel by Dispanfan (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
  20. Anything You Knead (Doey x Reader) by arimbaudspierre (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))