Fics like The Proposal

Right after the movie ends, Ichabod pops the question.

You may also like

1. Something With Spiders by TonicClaw (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
2. St. Joseph's Shelter For Men by IchabodCranesLeftFoot, shiawasena_neko (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies), Sleepy Hollow (1999), more)
3. It's Hard To Rest by TonicClaw (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
4. A New Start by DJFireHawk (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
5. Unwell by shiawasena_neko (Edward Scissorhands (1990), Sleepy Hollow (1999), more)
6. Truth Or Dare(Devil) by YunaYamiMouto (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
7. Four Little Words Challenge by RussianWitch (Phantom of the Opera (2004), Van Helsing (2004), more)
8. A Year to the Day by Cameo (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
9. Late Night Visitor by lilac_lungs (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
10. Seeing Is Believing by zzoaozz (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
11. Winter's Kiss by zzoaozz (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
12. Who Startled The Crow Of My Heart by NinaMaya (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Sleepy Hollow (1999))
13. Confessions by orphan_account (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
14. Tim Burton (One Shots Book) by KAckerman (Edward Scissorhands (1990), Dark Shadows (2012), more)
15. Mistress of All He Had by featherxquill (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
16. More Than Evil Remains by zzoaozz (Sleepy Hollow (1999), X-Men (Comicverse))
17. At peace at last by RussianWitch (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
18. In The Arms Of The Dead by zzoaozz (Sleepy Hollow (1999))
19. so no head? by fairyysoup (The Legend of Sleepy Hollow - All Media Types, Sleepy Hollow (1999))
20. I Won't Smile (but I'll show you my teeth) by LadySlytherin (Teen Wolf (TV), Sleepy Hollow (1999))