Fics like The Club (That's Made For You and Me)

Cleaves Mills, Maine. Current day. There are all kinds of people with precognitive abilities out there, and Sam wants to talk to one: Johnny Smith.

You may also like

1. Run for the Sand Wastes by Kita42 (Welcome to Night Vale, Supernatural)
2. Fire With Fire by Udunie (Teen Wolf (TV), Supernatural)
3. Turn It Up To Eleven by Strangevisitor7 (Supernatural, MacGyver (TV))
4. Never Never Land by Moonbeam (Supernatural, Transformers (Bayverse))
5. Baking for the Dead by InsaneTrollLogic (Pushing Daisies (TV 2007), Supernatural)
6. Not Quite The Devil You Know by Taranea (Supernatural, Good Omens - Neil Gaiman & Terry Pratchett)
7. Twist and Shout by gabriel, standbyme (Supernatural)
8. It Can't Rain All the Time by leonidaslion (Supernatural, The Crow (1994))
9. The Hunter and the Wizard by Slayer_of_Destiny (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Supernatural)
10. The Bizarre Winchester Murder Spree by Origamidragons (Supernatural, Buzzfeed Unsolved (Web Series))
11. If I Claim to Be a Wise Man by VerityBrown (The Shannara Chronicles (TV), Supernatural)
12. Baby Blue by Edwardina (Supernatural)
13. California Encounters by Redrikki (Psych, Supernatural, more)
14. Ninety One Whiskey by komodobits (Supernatural)
15. Age Shall Not Wither Her by chaletian (Supernatural, Waiting For God)
16. Salt of the Earth by yaycoffee (Supernatural, Joan of Arcadia)
17. Lollies and Loki by cheshire_carroll (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Supernatural)
18. Burnt Ash and Golden Eyes by InsaneTrollLogic (Psych, Supernatural)
19. This Bitter Earth by art_savage (Supernatural, Criminal Minds)
20. Eat it Twilight by liliaeth (Supernatural, Criminal Minds)