Fics like Baking for the Dead

In which the girl called Chuck and the Pie Maker runs across the brothers Winchester and a soul stealing demon.

You may also like

1. The Request by cloudyjenn (Supernatural)
2. No Difference by The_Bookkeeper (Supernatural, Criminal Minds)
3. Do Not Meddle by The_Bookkeeper (Supernatural)
4. Victor of the 57th Annual Hunger Games by bubblewrapstargirl (Supernatural, Hunger Games Trilogy - Suzanne Collins, more)
5. How to Romance a Human by cloudyjenn (Supernatural)
6. Harbor in the Storm by Semira (Supernatural)
7. Five times Mary Winchester tried to wrap her head around Castiel, Angel of the Lord, and one time she didn’t by karoffelbrei89 (Supernatural)
8. the type who doesn't burn by patrocluus (Supernatural)
9. Shelter by aeli_kindara (Supernatural)
10. Get out of jail for free-card by schrijverr (Supernatural)
11. Cracks in the Walls by ghostboi (Supernatural)
12. Phantom of the Panic Room by Runs_With_Wolves1 (Supernatural, Danny Phantom)
13. Negative Space by Las (Supernatural)
14. The Bizarre Winchester Murder Spree by Origamidragons (Supernatural, Buzzfeed Unsolved (Web Series))
15. Resurrection by The_Bookkeeper (Supernatural)
16. the angels never arrived (but i can hear the choir) by orphan_account (Supernatural, Good Omens - Neil Gaiman & Terry Pratchett)
17. Killer Blonde by aldersprig (Legally Blonde (Movies), Supernatural)
18. as a falling leaf may rest by myaimistrue (Supernatural)
19. A Simple Broken Leg by orphan_account (Supernatural)
20. outwardly respectable by sheepishlion (Supernatural)