Fics like Previous Engagement

Luke never really stopped liking Marnie Piper. He tried to, he really did. He turned to dating apps, and he tried to find someone who could fill the Marnie-shaped hole in his heart. No one ever seemed to stick around. But when he runs into Marnie again after years, he finds out that she's engaged, and that his chance to be with her has well and truly passed. (Or has it?) Marnie thinks that she's destined to be with Ethan Dalloway. They've been dating since college, and engaged for two years. Despite what she tells herself, however, her relationship is far from paradise. Feeling neglected and unappreciated, Marnie finds solace in an old friend. As her relationship begins to unravel on its own, Marnie senses that her feelings for Luke might be changing.

You may also like

  1. what's a few years to a witch and a goblin by MicrosuedeMouse (Halloweentown (1998))
  2. Take Me By Surprise by MicrosuedeMouse (Halloweentown (1998))
  3. Halloweentown Official's Blessing by BeneaththeBrim (天官赐福 - 墨香铜臭 | Tiān Guān Cì Fú - Mòxiāng Tóngxiù, Halloweentown (1998))
  4. A Family Tradition by Cadhla (Halloweentown (1998))
  5. Dance Macabre by Cadhla (Halloweentown (1998))
  6. Be Mine Spooky by OceanHeart23 (Halloweentown (1998))
  7. The Blue Collar Creeps by LivingOutLoud (Halloweentown (1998))
  8. Halloweentown 3: Fright Knights by JokeHunk (Halloweentown (1998))
  9. Dcoms and disney movies short prompt stories by Samjr04 (High School Musical (Movies), Descendants (Disney Movies), more)
  10. Charmed What If. (What if someone was there to save Prue after the reset of the timeline to save the Charmed ones.) by EmoKitty21 (Charmed (TV 1998), Halloweentown (1998))
  11. Divergent by Are_you_ever_not_going_to_fall_for_that (Halloweentown (1998))
  12. Mortal Jeopardy by elyssblair (Halloweentown (1998))
  13. Time-Lapse Reveals Sleight of Hand by galfridian (Halloweentown (1998))
  14. Hallows by Abrus (Halloweentown (1998))
  15. Alex In HalloweenTown by gambitsgeekyprincess (Julie and The Phantoms (TV), Halloweentown (1998), more)
  16. Lorelei Cromwell by AtomicDC (Halloweentown (1998))
  17. Mischief in Halloweentown by MerCevans (Teen Wolf (TV), Halloweentown (1998))
  18. Prompts and Tiniest Things by aHostileRainbow (The Hobbit - All Media Types, Pocahontas (1995), more)
  19. Sunday Morning Tension by Prismatic (Halloweentown (1998))
  20. Unite by DollopheadedMerlin (Merlin (TV), Halloweentown (1998))