Fics like Take Me By Surprise

Five times out of many, post-university, that Marnie surprises Luke, and the one occasion that he manages to surprise her back.

You may also like

1. Be Mine Spooky by OceanHeart23 (Halloweentown (1998))
2. Spell It Out by carolinecrane (Halloweentown (1998))
3. Family Secrets by thesearewords (Halloweentown (1998))
4. Prompts and Tiniest Things by aHostileRainbow (The Hobbit - All Media Types, Pocahontas (1995), more)
5. The Mortal Kind by candidcryptid (Halloweentown (1998))
6. what's a few years to a witch and a goblin by MicrosuedeMouse (Halloweentown (1998))
7. Halloweentown 3: Fright Knights by JokeHunk (Halloweentown (1998))
8. Not Enough by The_Shifting_Wix (Halloweentown (1998))
9. A Feeling by Mossoteric (Dead by Daylight (Video Game), Halloween Movies - All Media Types, more)
10. Time-Lapse Reveals Sleight of Hand by galfridian (Halloweentown (1998))
11. if we shadows by Strictly_Platonic (Teen Wolf (TV), Halloweentown (1998))
12. Sunday Morning Tension by Prismatic (Halloweentown (1998))
13. Dance Macabre by Cadhla (Halloweentown (1998))
14. Hallows by Abrus (Halloweentown (1998))
15. The Works Of A Killer's Lover || Slasher oneshots by orphan_account (The Boy (2016 Bell), The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Movies), more)
16. Halloweentown Official's Blessing by BeneaththeBrim (天官赐福 - 墨香铜臭 | Tiān Guān Cì Fú - Mòxiāng Tóngxiù, Halloweentown (1998))
17. Halloweentown Forever by Greyowl9831 (Halloweentown (1998))
18. Lorelei Cromwell by AtomicDC (Halloweentown (1998))
19. the other side of want by prettydizzeed (Halloweentown (1998))
20. better find another superstition by prettydizzeed (Halloweentown (1998))